Fluid Flow & Aerodynamics
why things fly, and why the usual explanation is wrong
Series

Structure function — the series

4 essays on one idea, from the one that introduces it to the one that assumes the rest.
  1. The one exact law, and where viscosity takes it back. The two terms of the Kármán–Howarth relation against separation, measured in Kolmogorov lengths. The four-fifths term rises linearly with r and is the whole of the law at large separation; the viscous term, 6ν dS₂/dr, falls as r^(−1/3) and takes over below 5.64η. Nothing in the calculation was told what η is: the crossing is at the same multiple of it at every viscosity tried, which is what makes the dissipation scale the lower end of the inertial range rather than a separate assumption.

    The one exact result

    Almost nothing in turbulence follows from the equations without a model in it. One thing does — Kolmogorov's four-fifths law, which fixes the third moment of the velocity differences at −(4/5)εr with no adjustable constant anywhere in it. The companion two-thirds law is not exact, and the 4.02 everybody quotes in it turns out to be a gamma function.

    part 1 · turbulence
  2. Four over the dimension, and three dimensions is where the three comes from. The constant in front of the exact law, against the number of dimensions the flow lives in. Both exact results — Yaglom's for a scalar and the velocity's law for the mixed third moment — have this same constant, because both come from the same statement: an isotropic radial flux in separation space whose divergence is a constant sink. Integrating that divergence gives 4Q r/d and nothing else. The four-thirds everybody quotes is four over three, and the three is the space rather than anything about turbulence. The dots are the quadrature, which agrees with the closed form to 2·10⁻⁹.

    The fraction that is really four thirds

    Turbulence has two exact results, not one. The second is about a scalar carried by the flow, its constant is four thirds rather than four fifths, and the difference between the two fractions has nothing in it about turbulence at all — it is the price of writing a three-component object in terms of one component.

    part 2 · turbulence
  3. One curve from two to one, with four thirds somewhere in the middle. The ratio of the transverse second-order structure function to the longitudinal one, against separation, at three Reynolds numbers. Every value on every curve follows from the longitudinal function alone by a relation with no dynamics in it. It is exactly 2 where the field is smooth, exactly 1 beyond the correlation length, and it passes through four thirds on the way — but it passes through rather than resting there, and how nearly it rests is the whole of what a Reynolds number buys.

    A relation with no turbulence in it

    Isotropy and incompressibility alone fix the transverse structure function from the longitudinal one. Divide the relation through and it says the ratio of the two is one plus half the local slope — so the exponent everybody measures as 0.70 and the ratio everybody measures as 1.35 are one measurement, and a model spectrum with no intermittency in it produces both.

    part 3 · turbulence
  4. At fourth order a local slope reports less than a quarter of the anomaly. The anomaly each instrument reports at Reλ = 200 — Kolmogorov's n/3 less what it reads — against the order, for the log-normal field with μ = 0.25, with the departure its distribution carries. The local slope reports 0.026 of a true 0.111 at fourth order and 0.205 of 0.333 at sixth; extended self-similarity 0.245 of its own 0.261; the normalised moment reports the truth at every order.

    At higher orders the bottleneck hides intermittency

    At second order the spectral bottleneck makes a field with no intermittency look intermittent. At higher orders it does the opposite. Every moment's local slope is steepened by the same finite-Reynolds-number excess, multiplied by half the order, while the intermittency correction pulls the other way. At a laboratory Reynolds number a fitted sixth-order exponent therefore shows less than two-thirds of the anomaly the field carries, and a fourth-order one less than a quarter.

    part 4 · turbulence

All series