Taper — the series · Fluid Flow & Aerodynamics

The rectangular wing stalls at the root; the tapered one stalls at the tip. Section lift coefficient across the half span for three planforms, each drawn at the wing incidence where its own worst section first reaches 1.5. A rectangular wing's peak is at the root, which is where a designer wants it: the stall starts inboard, ahead of the ailerons, and the pilot feels it. A tapered wing's peak has moved out to 0.62 of the semi-span — over the ailerons — because taper takes chord away from the tip faster than it takes circulation. The elliptic wing is the degenerate case: every section reaches the limit at once, which is elegant and is the worst possible stall behaviour.

Which part of a wing stalls first

A wing has one lift coefficient and its sections have a hundred, and no section is at the wing's. Which of them runs out first is decided by the planform, it decides whether the pilot keeps the ailerons, and on any wing that was close to elliptic the standard fix costs span efficiency for every degree of it applied.

part 1 · circulation

How flat the optimum is. The same curve near its maximum, with the bands within a tenth and a half of one per cent of the best shaded. Every taper ratio from 0.31 to 0.42 is within a tenth of a per cent of the optimum, and the whole band from 0.25 to 0.51 is within half a per cent. The optimum is exact, and choosing it rather than its neighbour buys nothing a wing can measure.

The optimum that does not matter

Elliptic loading gives the least induced drag, exactly, and the proof is one line: the penalty is a sum of squares. Which is also why the optimum is flat enough that a quarter of the design space sits inside a tenth of a per cent of it.

part 2 · circulation

A washed-out rectangular wing is at its best at one lift coefficient. The span efficiency of a rectangular wing of aspect ratio 8 against lift coefficient, untwisted and with 2°, 4° and 6° of washout. Untwisted, it is 0.9367 at every lift coefficient. Each washout has one lift coefficient where it is best — 0.254, 0.509 and 0.763 — proportional to the twist, and each reaches the same peak, 0.9911, there. Below the peak the efficiency falls fast.

Washout is right at one lift coefficient

A twisted wing's loading is the sum of two shapes in a proportion that changes with speed, so its induced drag is a parabola in lift coefficient with its least at one design point, and that point moves in proportion to the twist. On a rectangular wing four degrees of washout puts it at a lift coefficient of 0.51 and recovers almost all the span efficiency the planform lost. On a well-tapered wing the same four degrees puts it at nineteen, and the washout is a drag paid at every speed for the stall alone.

part 3 · circulation

A trainer's sortie wants the washout of its cruise, not of its average. The span efficiency of a rectangular wing of aspect ratio 8 averaged over a training sortie — eight minutes' climb, thirty of cruise, ten of slow flight and twelve of circuits — against its linear washout. Untwisted it is 0.9367. The best washout for the sortie is 3.43°, reaching 0.9774: the optimum for a lift coefficient of 0.436, the distance-weighted harmonic mean of the sortie's. The cruise alone would want 2.6°; the time-averaged lift coefficient, 0.671, would want 5.28° and lose 1.2% of the efficiency.

One twist is chosen for the speed flown per metre

A twisted wing is best at one lift coefficient and an aeroplane flies at many. Average its induced drag over a flight the way fuel and height are actually spent, per metre, and the twist that wins is the one for the root-mean-square speed of the flight — so the cruise outvotes the slow flight, a glider's circling barely counts, and a trainer's usual three or four degrees of washout turn out to be right for reasons nobody fitted them for.

part 4 · circulation

The washout a mission wants rises with the lift coefficient; a twist driven by dynamic pressure rises the other way. Washout against lift coefficient for the trainer's sortie: each lift coefficient's own best washout, 7.87° per unit of it; the best fixed washout, 3.43°; the best twist that varies with dynamic pressure, which has to wash in as the aeroplane speeds up; and a twist of the natural sign, one degree of extra washout at cruise growing with dynamic pressure, from a nose-down pitching moment. The four segments sit at Cₗ 0.82, 0.33, 1.3, 0.92.

A wing that twists with its speed washes out the wrong way

A fixed washout is right at one lift coefficient, and a flight that spends its time at four of them pays for the spread. A wing whose twist changed in flight could follow — but the twist a real wing gets for free is driven by dynamic pressure, and it adds washout as the aeroplane speeds up, exactly where less is wanted. On a trainer's sortie a degree of it at cruise raises the induced energy by a third of a point. The best twist driven by dynamic pressure washes in, and only one that follows the incidence itself removes the spread entirely.

part 5 · circulation

A symmetric panel with no spring stiffness washes out exactly as each lift coefficient wants. The outer panel's washout against the wing's lift coefficient over the trainer's sortie, with a spring stiffness of 0 cruise dynamic pressures: each lift coefficient's own best, 5.31° per unit of it; the best fixed washout, 2.31°; a symmetric panel at its best hinge and preload, 1.34% above an elliptic wing; and a panel with a cambered trainer section's moment of −0.05, 9.31%. The fixed twist spends 2.65% and the floor is 1.34%.

A pivoted wingtip follows the lift only with no spring stiffness and no camber

The washout a trainer's sortie wants grows in proportion to the lift coefficient, and the twist a wing gets for free follows the dynamic pressure instead. A tip panel free to pivot on a hinge ahead of its own aerodynamic centre can do better, and on one condition it does exactly what is wanted: held by a constant torque and carrying no camber moment, its own lift coefficient stays in proportion to the wing's, and every segment of the sortie flies at its own best twist. Every unit of spring stiffness gives part of that back, a cambered section's moment turns the panel into the wrong law altogether, and the free panel sheds a quarter of a gust's lift for nothing.

part 6 · circulation