Theme

The thread: One number decides the regime — page 19

Page 19 of 34, continuing through the 305 essays this motif runs through.

305 essays carry this thread — page 19 of 34.

$A swimmer that dissipates the same everywhere. Taylor's waving sheet, with the wave drawn along the bottom and the dissipation drawn against height above it. The dissipation function works out at 4μb²c²k⁶y²e^{−2ky} — with no x in it at all, so the sheet is destroying energy at the same rate under every part of the wave and at every instant of the cycle. It peaks one radian of wavelength above the sheet and is gone within about three.$ Viscosity

A swimmer that cannot go backwards

Taylor's waving sheet is the simplest self-propelled object in a viscous fluid, and its arithmetic contains a result that reads like a mistake — the work it does to travel a metre does not depend on how big its waves are. Doubling the amplitude quadruples both the speed and the power, and changes the bill for the journey by nothing at all.

Nu/√Re against the Prandtl number, over eight decades. The whole of the flat plate's heat transfer, as one curve. It is not a power law: it goes as Pr^½ at the bottom, where the thermal layer is far thicker than the viscous one, and as Pr^⅓ at the top, where it is buried inside it. The Pr^⅓ everybody quotes is the upper half. The two asymptotes are drawn beside it, and the low one is √(Pr/π) in closed form.

Regimes and numbers

The number that is an answer

Almost every dimensionless group is a hypothesis: somebody sets the speed, the size and the fluid, and the number licenses a model. The Nusselt number is not. It is what the experiment produces, it sits on the left of the equals sign, and a regime diagram drawn on it is a category error.

A normal stress the closure makes negative. The Boussinesq closure's first normal stress in a plane strain, against the strain measured in units of the turbulence's own time scale. It crosses zero at S k/eps = 1/(3 C_mu) = 3.704 — eleven per cent above the value the constant was calibrated at — and goes on falling. A variance below zero is not a small error; it is a statement that cannot be true.

Transition and turbulence

The constant that makes a variance negative

Every engineering turbulence calculation in the world rests on one number, C-mu equals 0.09. It is not a property of turbulence. It is the assertion that a particular ratio is ten thirds, which is true in one flow — and eleven per cent above that flow the same closure reports a mean square below zero.

A compression piston, and where its characteristics first cross. Sixty C+ characteristics from an accelerating piston, drawn in the distance-time plane. Each is a straight line, because the invariant makes the state along it constant; later ones are faster, because the gas ahead of them has been compressed; so they converge, and the first crossing is the shock. The envelope formula gives 2.7529 and the first actual crossing is at 2.7510.

Compressible flow

Two numbers that do not change

One-dimensional unsteady gas flow carries two quantities that are exactly constant along two families of curves. That single fact turns a pair of coupled partial differential equations into a family of straight lines, and gives an exact speed at which a gas outruns its own expansion.

Five approach profiles a meter might be looking at. The velocity across the pipe upstream of a contraction, for a uniform flow, fully developed laminar flow, two turbulent power laws and an annular jet of the kind a bend or a partly open valve leaves. All five carry the same volume flow. The meter reads a pressure difference and cannot see any of this.

Fluids at work

The profile a meter cannot see

A differential-pressure flowmeter measures a force balance and reports a flow rate. The step between them needs two integrals of a velocity profile the instrument has no access to — and two profiles differing by half the mean velocity across the pipe give identical readings, which is why the standards specify straight pipe rather than a correction.

One pair of strainings, two orders, two lengths. The stretch of the most-stretched material direction against time, for a simple shear followed by a pure strain and for the same two in the other order. The two curves are identical until the swap and separate afterwards, ending a factor of 2.16 apart.

Flows and fields

Two strainings, and the order they came in

A material line is stretched by a shear and then by a pure strain, and then by the same two in the other order. Every instantaneous measure of how hard the fluid was being worked is identical in the two cases. The lengths at the end differ by a factor of 2.16.

Two integrands, and the wrong one claims 9.58 per cent more drag. The two things that get integrated across a wake, each scaled to its own peak so the shapes can be compared. The momentum integrand u(U − u)/U² is the drag; the mass integrand (U − u)/U is the displacement thickness, and it is not a drag at all. They differ by a factor of u/U inside them, so the mass one is fatter wherever the deficit is deep — and its integral here is 1.1 times the momentum one's. That ratio is decided by how deep the wake is rather than by how wide: at a twentieth of this momentum thickness it falls to 1, and at twice it rises to 1.25. The error is smallest exactly where a survey is properly done, far downstream where the wake has spread and shallowed.

What is taught wrongly

Weighing what is missing

A control volume drawn round a wing gets the lift out of it, on a flow that was solved exactly. The wake survey asks the same box for the drag on a flow nobody has solved, and it is how a real aerofoil's drag is known — with three assumptions, all of which are checkable, and one integral standing next to it that is wrong.

The marginal Taylor number against the axial wavenumber. The smallest Taylor number at which a disturbance of a given axial wavenumber is neutral. Its minimum is 1707.757 at a wavenumber of 3.1158, which are the critical Rayleigh number and critical wavenumber of a layer of fluid heated between two rigid walls — the same numbers, because in the narrow-gap limit the two problems are the same sixth-order eigenvalue problem. This curve is computed by that essay's own solver.

Regimes and numbers

A transition that needs a second number

Fluid between rotating cylinders goes unstable at a Taylor number of 1707.762 — which is the same number, to every digit, as a layer of fluid heated between two rigid walls. It is not an analogy. And two things the number cannot carry decide whether the transition happens at all and what it looks like when it does.

Circulation and lift

The side that cannot keep up

A hovering rotor is axisymmetric, so one radial distribution of circulation describes the whole disc. Move it forward and the advancing blade meets one and a half times the tip speed while the retreating one meets a half — and lift goes as the square of that. The rotor does not roll over, because the pitch is made a function of azimuth.

All themes