Theme

The thread: The exact theory is wrong — page 19

Page 19 of 22, continuing through the 193 essays this motif runs through.

193 essays carry this thread — page 19 of 22.

$A keel pulls the best beat 12 degrees closer to the wind. Speed made good as a fraction of the wind against the course, in 3 m/s: for the boat with its keel solved as a wing, and for a boat whose λ is fixed at 25.69°, the value the keeled boat has on its own best course. The search puts the keeled boat's best beat at 45.83°; the fixed-angle rule puts it at 45° + λ/2 = 57.84°. Pointing higher loads the keel towards its best lift coefficient — 0.130 at 40° against 0.076 at 60° — and lowers its drag angle, so the curve peaks early and falls away faster on the far side. The fixed-angle curve promises 0.653 of the wind; the keeled boat can make 0.553, and only by sailing twelve degrees higher than the rule says.$ Fluids at work

A keel flies wherever the course puts it

A keel is a wing whose lift is whatever side force the rig happens to make, so its lift coefficient is chosen by the course and the wind rather than by its designer. Solved that way, the hull's drag angle stops being a property of the boat: it pulls the best beat twelve degrees closer to the wind, halves the reaching speed a fixed angle predicts, and finally charges for reefing.

With friction the flow goes sonic after the throat, and leaves slower. The Mach number along a convergent–divergent nozzle of exit area ratio 2.5, for friction lengths 4fL/Dₜ of 0, 0.2 and 1, each solution passing smoothly through Mach 1 at the point where the sonic condition holds. Without friction that point is the throat, at x = 0.42. With friction it moves downstream — to 0.4357 and 0.4996 — and the throat itself is subsonic, at Mach 0.965 and 0.852. The exit Mach number falls from 2.443 to 2.247 and 1.747. The throat is where the area is least; the sonic point is where the widening has caught up with the friction, and the two coincide only when there is none.

Compressible flow

Friction moves the sonic point past the throat

A choked nozzle is sonic at its throat — in a nozzle with frictionless walls. With friction the flow reaches Mach one where the section's widening rate has caught up with the friction, which is downstream of the throat, and the throat itself is subsonic. The solution through that point is a saddle that can only be found from the inside, and the mass flow it passes is less than the throat's area allows.

Three modes carry heat up to a ceiling of three; the rolls they were cut from keep going. The Nusselt number — heat carried across the layer over what conduction alone would carry — against r, the Rayleigh number over its critical value, for Lorenz's three-mode truncation, 1 + 2(r − 1)/r, and for steady rolls at the same wavenumber computed with 6 and with 42 temperature modes. At r = 2, r = 5 and r = 30 Lorenz gives 2.000, 2.600 and 2.933; the 42-mode rolls give 2.143, 3.323 and 5.970. Lorenz's value can never exceed three whatever the Rayleigh number; the rolls' keeps rising. The ceiling is not in the convection. It is in the three modes, which have only one way to thin the thermal layers, and half of it is used by the time the layer is twice past onset.

Transition and turbulence

The truncation that cannot carry three times the heat

Lorenz's three modes give a convecting layer's heat flux in one line — one plus twice (r − 1) over r — and it can never reach three times what conduction carries. The same rolls computed with forty-two modes agree with that line exactly at onset, carry 7.1 per cent more heat at twice the critical Rayleigh number, and twice as much at thirty times it. The ceiling is not in the convection; it is in having one sine to draw the temperature with.

One body, three interior representations. An ellipse four fifths as tall as it is long, in a uniform stream, with three sets of singularities inside it: a point doublet at the centre, a ring of them at four tenths of the semi-major axis, and a uniform disc of them. Outside the ring the three produce the identical flow to fifteen figures. Inside, they are not remotely the same field.

Ideal flow

The inside a flow does not decide

Every body on this site is built out of singularities that are not there. The exterior flow does not merely fail to determine them — it leaves an infinite family, whose members produce the identical field to the last bit outside and are nothing alike inside, and whose coefficients span five orders of magnitude for one unit free stream.

The wake's memory, as a gain and a phase. Theodorsen's lift deficiency against reduced frequency. It is one at zero frequency — the quasi-steady limit, where the wake has had time to convect away — and falls to a half at high frequency, with a phase lag peaking near 15 degrees in between.

Circulation and lift

The lag that makes flutter possible

This site's own flutter model set the lift deficiency to one and recorded in its notes that doing so throws away the lag which stabilises the torsion mode. Putting the lag back moves the flutter speed from 80.8 metres a second to 131, and removes the need for the structural damping that was covering the artefact.

Regimes and numbers

Slip is a memory of one mean free path

A molecule arriving at a wall last collided about a mean free path away and carries the velocity from there. Averaged over arrivals and departures, that leaves the gas at the wall moving — by two per cent of the centreline speed at a Knudsen number of a hundredth, and sixty per cent more flow through a microchannel at a tenth.

121 m after the cavity closes, against 69 m from the closure. The head at a valve shut instantly on water flowing at 0.36 m/s through 600 m of 100 mm pipe, a = 1200 m/s, with a steady head of 25 m. The closure raises it to 69.1 m, the Joukowsky head; the reflection returns at one round trip, 1.00 s, and takes the head down to the vapour head, −10.1 m, where a cavity opens (shaded). It closes 2.146 round trips after the closure, and the first pulse after it reaches 121.3 m — 52.3 m above the Joukowsky head — for 146 ms. The step line is the exact solution between events; the thin line is a 240-reach grid solver that was told nothing about it and agrees with its first pulse to better than a millimetre.

Fluids at work

Twice the margin, on top of the hammer

Shut a valve on a line whose pressure is low and the returning wave boils the water beside it. When that cavity closes, the head at the valve can pass the Joukowsky rise — by up to twice the margin that let the water boil, in a sawtooth that jumps each time one more round trip fits into the cavity's life, and for a time that is shortest exactly when the pulse is tallest.

A 20° cone at Mach 2: the shock at 37.80°, and a flow still compressing behind it. The conical flow round a cone of 20° half-angle at Mach 2, from the Taylor–Maccoll equation. The shock sits at 37.80° from the axis and turns the flow crossing it through only 8.57°, leaving it at Mach 1.693. Between the shock and the surface every ray from the apex carries its own state: the Mach number falls from 1.693 just behind the shock to 1.568 at the surface and the pressure rises from 1.586 to 1.912 times the free stream's — the rest of the turn, made without a shock. Nothing depends on the distance from the apex, so the rays are lines of constant state.

Compressible flow

A cone finishes its turn after the shock

A wedge turns a supersonic stream all at once, at its shock. A cone of the same angle does not: its shock turns the flow only part of the way and leaves the rest to a smooth compression between the shock and the surface. Solved from Taylor and Maccoll's equation, the cone's shock is weaker, keeps more of the total pressure, carries less than half the wedge's surface pressure, and stays attached to 40.7° at Mach 2 where the wedge gives up at 23°.

$The shaded face's share of the force is set by K, and it is not small until K is. The fraction of a flat plate's normal force carried by its leeward face against K = M sin α, at Mach 3, 5, 10, 20, with the hypersonic small-disturbance value and the share the leeward face would have at vacuum (dashed). Newtonian theory puts it at zero. The curves collapse on K: the small-disturbance share is 35.7 per cent at K = 0.5, 24.2 at 1, 11.2 at 2 and 3.4 at 4, and the vacuum bound is 28.8, 11.4 and 3.4 per cent at 1, 2 and 4. The zero is a good approximation only where K is large — which is also the only place the Newtonian windward pressure is itself accurate.$ What is taught wrongly

The face Newton left in shadow

Newtonian theory gives a surface turned away from the stream a pressure coefficient of exactly zero, and at hypersonic speed the rest of the theory is nearly right. The shaded face is not. Computed exactly on a flat plate, its share of the force depends on the similarity parameter K = M sin α rather than on the Mach number, it is a quarter of the force at K = 1, and it moves a hypersonic plate's best lift-to-drag ratio from 5 to 7 at Mach 10.

All themes