Fluid Flow & Aerodynamics
why things fly, and why the usual explanation is wrong
Theme

The thread: The exact theory is wrong — page 2

Page 2 of 22, continuing through the 193 essays this motif runs through.

193 essays carry this thread — page 2 of 22.

The energy is all there the whole way: enthalpy spent to buy speed. At each Mach number, the fraction of the stagnation enthalpy still held as heat and the fraction converted into directed motion. The two always sum to the total, which is the compressible replacement for Bernoulli's equation — an energy statement rather than a pressure one. At Mach 2 more than four fifths of the heat has become speed. Compressible flow

Energy instead of pressure

Bernoulli's equation is a statement that pressure and speed trade against each other at fixed density. Take the fixed density away and the trade is between heat and speed instead — and what survives is not a pressure at all.

 Ideal flow past a cylinder. A uniform stream past a circular cylinder in a fluid with no viscosity. The solution is exact and closed-form: streamlines part at a stagnation point, run round the surface and close up perfectly behind, and the pressure recovers to exactly what it was in front. Ideal flow

Flows add up

The equations of ideal flow are linear, so solutions can be laid on top of one another. A uniform stream plus a doublet produces a cylinder that nobody put there, and almost every classical result is built this way.

 Flow past a cylinder at Re 100. A real fluid past a circular cylinder. At low Reynolds number the flow closes up behind the body much as the ideal theory says; as it rises the flow separates and a region of reversed flow appears behind, which is where drag comes from. Viscosity

The two theories, side by side

The exact solution and the real flow, for the same body in the same stream. One is beautiful and predicts nothing has drag; the other is approximate and has a wake in it. Where they agree and where they part is the whole map of the subject.

 A Joukowski aerofoil at 6°. A cambered aerofoil in a uniform stream. The circulation is not chosen: it is whatever value makes the flow leave the sharp trailing edge smoothly, and that single condition fixes the lift. Circulation and lift

The lift curve, and why it is a straight line

Lift against angle of attack is a straight line, it does not pass through the origin, and its slope is very close to a number that has no business being there. All three facts fall out of the theory.

 Betz's ceiling, and the rotor that cannot reach it. The power coefficient of Glauert's optimum rotor against tip-speed ratio, with Betz's 16/27 drawn as the ceiling it is. The gap is wake rotation: a rotor that extracts power applies a torque, a torque leaves the wake spinning, and that rotational energy never reaches the shaft. It falls as the rotor is geared up and is never zero — which is why large wind turbines turn so slowly and yet have such fast tips. Fluids at work

The wake that has to spin

A rotor that takes power out of the wind must apply a torque to it, and a torque applied to air is angular momentum left behind. The axial theory has nowhere to put that energy, so Betz's ceiling is unreachable at every finite tip-speed ratio — and the gap is computable.

 Mach number: one number, four different flows. Mach number is speed ÷ speed of sound. It is not a property of the fluid or of the shape but of the combination, and crossing a threshold changes the physics rather than the magnitude. Regimes and numbers

When air stops being incompressible

Air is a gas and can obviously be squeezed, yet most of aerodynamics treats its density as fixed. The assumption holds until the flow approaches the speed at which pressure information travels — and then everything changes at once.

 Every wavelength grows, and the shortest grows fastest. Growth rate against wavenumber for a vortex sheet of zero thickness and for a layer of thickness δ. The sheet's curve rises without limit, which is the model announcing that it has no shortest scale in it; the layer's turns over and dies at kδ = 1, the neutral wavenumber computed from Rayleigh's equation rather than fitted. Transition and turbulence

Every wavelength at once

A vortex sheet of zero thickness is unstable at every wavelength, and the shorter the wavelength the faster it grows. The answer has no smallest scale in it, which is not a fact about fluids — it is the model reporting that it left something out.

 Ideal flow past a cylinder with circulation -3.4. A uniform stream past a circular cylinder in a fluid with no viscosity. The solution is exact and closed-form: streamlines part at a stagnation point, run round the surface and close up perfectly behind, and the pressure recovers to exactly what it was in front. Circulation and lift

Lift with no wing at all

A spinning cylinder has no camber, no aerofoil section and no trailing edge, and it lifts exactly as hard as its circulation says it should. Which settles what lift is caused by.

 Flow net — a stream past a cylinder. Two families of curves drawn over the same flow: the streamlines, along which the streamfunction is constant, and the equipotentials, along which the velocity potential is constant. They cross at right angles at every point, because they are the two parts of a single analytic function of position. Ideal flow

One function instead of two

A velocity field carries two numbers at every point and must satisfy two constraints. Both constraints can be solved once and for all by writing the whole flow as a single scalar function — and the two families of curves that function generates cross at right angles everywhere, for reasons that have nothing to do with fluids.

All themes