Fluid Flow & Aerodynamics
why things fly, and why the usual explanation is wrong
Theme

The thread: A smooth picture proves nothing — page 13

Page 13 of 20, continuing through the 172 essays this motif runs through.

172 essays carry this thread — page 13 of 20.

The stretching a window of history did, drawn as a field. The largest finite-time Lyapunov exponent over eight units of time in the double gyre, darkest where two neighbouring parcels were pulled furthest apart. The bright crest is a curve across the domain, and it is a property of the eight units rather than of any instant inside them. Flows and fields

A boundary that only exists over a window

The curve that separates fluid going one way from fluid going another is not in any snapshot of the flow. It is the crest of a field built from a stretch of history, it moves when the stretch is changed, and reversing the direction of time gives a different curve entirely — both of them real.

 A degree of temperature is worth 0.34 per cent of pressure. The error in the pressure a paint reports, against how much warmer the surface is at the test condition than at the reference, at four pressures. At 0.8 of the reference pressure the sensitivity is -0.34 per cent of pressure per kelvin, so 10 degrees is -3.45 per cent. That is not a small number against what the technique is used to measure, and a model's surface temperature is not uniform: it is warmer where the flow has been brought to rest and cooler where it has accelerated, which means the temperature error is largest exactly where the pressure gradients are. The standard remedy is a second, temperature-sensitive paint measured at the same time — an instrument added to correct an instrument. What is taught wrongly

The paint that measures the wrong field

Dye, seeded particles and the optical methods all look through the flow or at something put in it. Pressure-sensitive paint looks at the surface, reports a scalar rather than a derivative, and turns a row of taps into a field. What quenches its luminescence is oxygen, which is what makes it a pressure gauge — and temperature, which is the other field a flow is guaranteed to produce.

 The wall shear, marched to the station where it stops. Howarth's linearly retarded outer flow, marched with an implicit finite-difference scheme from a Blasius profile. The wall shear falls, its slope steepens, and at x = 0.11983 it reaches zero — against Howarth's 0.1198, which is a quarter of a per cent. There is nothing downstream of it: the solution does not continue. Viscosity

The singularity a layer makes for itself

March Prandtl's equations into an adverse pressure gradient and the wall shear reaches zero with an infinite slope at a finite station, and the solution cannot be continued past it. The singularity is real, it is not a numerical difficulty, and it belongs to the boundary condition rather than to the equations.

 Two flows with one mean profile. The time-averaged velocity of a plain shear and of the same shear carrying a zero-mean disturbance. There is one line on this plot: the largest difference anywhere across the channel is four parts in 10¹⁷. Flows and fields

What a mean profile cannot tell anybody

Two flows are built here with mean velocity profiles that agree to four parts in 10¹⁷. One of them carries momentum across the shear and dissipates forty per cent more energy; the other carries nothing. Everything that distinguishes them is second order in a disturbance the mean cannot see at all.

 The four waves, and the one that never goes away. The shock tube in space and time: a shock running right, an expansion fan running left, and the contact surface between them. The shock and the fan are travelling disturbances that leave; the contact is made of fluid, so it is carried along and is there for ever. Compressible flow

A surface that remembers the diaphragm

Between the shock and the expansion in a shock tube there is a surface across which the pressure and the velocity are identical and the temperature differs by a factor of two. It is made of fluid, so it never goes away, and nothing in the pressure field says it is there.

 Four wall models, through the buffer layer. Van Driest's damped mixing length, Reichardt's fit, Spalding's implicit law, and a control with no buffer layer at all — the viscous sublayer joined straight to the logarithm where they cross, at y+ = 11.6. The three fitted models agree with each other to a per cent and a half; the control is nineteen per cent above them at y+ = 10. Transition and turbulence

Three buffer layers, one friction

Four wall models are put through a pipe. The one with no buffer layer at all is nineteen per cent wrong where the turbulence production peaks and two and a half per cent wrong in the friction; the three respectable ones are within two per cent of each other in the buffer layer and spread by seven in the friction. The answer is not where it was expected.

 A duct that does not change, and a parcel that does. A contraction of area ratio four, with the parcel marked at five equal intervals of time. The walls do not move, the field at every point is the same at every instant, and the spacing of the markers grows because the parcel is carrying its own history through the duct. Flows and fields

How long the fluid has been in there

Age is the simplest thing a flow can remember. It obeys the shortest transport equation in the subject — its material derivative is one — and no instrument pointed at a steady flow can read it, because a steady flow's every field is constant and its fluid is getting older all the time.

 When the sound arriving now was made. The arrival time at a fixed observer against the emission time, for a source passing at Mach 0.8. The curve is monotone and its slope is not one: while the source approaches, a long stretch of emission arrives in a short stretch of time, and while it recedes the reverse. Compressible flow

The sound now is the source then

Every acoustic calculation is an exercise in bookkeeping about when. The pressure arriving at a listener was emitted at an earlier time, at a place the source has since left, and the Doppler shift is not a separate effect at all — it is the slope of the curve relating the two.

 A tube 10 cm across, spun: the lowest pressure is on the axis. The absolute pressure along a water-filled tube spun about its middle, open to the air at both ends, 5 cm from the axis. In the spinning frame the water is at rest under a centrifugal pull, so the pressure falls from atmospheric at each meniscus to its lowest on the axis, as a parabola. 10 thousand rpm puts −1.3 MPa there, 20 thousand rpm puts −5.4 MPa there, 30 thousand rpm puts −12.2 MPa there and 45 thousand rpm puts −27.6 MPa there. The place the water is stretched hardest is the place furthest from both free surfaces, which is the whole merit of the method: a gas cannot reach the liquid where it is weakest. What is taught wrongly

A breaking strength that is the size of a flaw

Water can be stretched, and how far is a measurement people have made for a century and a half with instruments that agree with one another and not with the theory. Spinning a tube puts the stretch where no gas can reach it, sealing one caps the stretch at water's density maximum, and every measured number turns out to name the size of the worst cavity in the sample.

All themes