Fluid Flow & Aerodynamics
why things fly, and why the usual explanation is wrong
Concept

Shear layer — where it appears

A thin region separating two streams of different speed, which carries all of the vorticity between them. It has an inflection point by construction, so it is unstable to disturbances of every wavelength and rolls up into discrete vortices.

Named by 9 essays across 4 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

A shear layer, and the point of inflection in it. The velocity profile U = tanh y across a layer of finite thickness, with the inflection point located by searching for a sign change in the second derivative rather than by reading it off the algebra. Rayleigh's theorem says an inviscid parallel flow can only be unstable if such a point exists — a necessary condition, not a sufficient one.

A layer with a kink in it

Rayleigh proved in 1880 that an inviscid shear flow cannot be unstable unless its velocity profile bends the other way somewhere. It is one line of algebra, it is necessary and not sufficient, and it ties instability to separation through the sign of a single derivative at the wall.

turbulence · Instability Every wavelength grows, and the shortest grows fastest. Growth rate against wavenumber for a vortex sheet of zero thickness and for a layer of thickness δ. The sheet's curve rises without limit, which is the model announcing that it has no shortest scale in it; the layer's turns over and dies at kδ = 1, the neutral wavenumber computed from Rayleigh's equation rather than fitted.

Every wavelength at once

A vortex sheet of zero thickness is unstable at every wavelength, and the shorter the wavelength the faster it grows. The answer has no smallest scale in it, which is not a fact about fluids — it is the model reporting that it left something out.

turbulence · Instability Q and the vorticity along a radius of one vortex. Two candidate measures of where the vortex is, along a radius of a Lamb–Oseen vortex. The vorticity is a Gaussian: positive at every radius, so a threshold on it puts the edge wherever the threshold is put. Q — the excess of rotation over strain — changes sign exactly once, at 1.121 core radii, and that radius is a property of the flow rather than of the person drawing it. Inside it, 71.5 per cent of the circulation.

Where a vortex stops

Four criteria decide where a vortex ends, and in two dimensions three of them are the same criterion. The fourth is a knob. And the one that is not a knob is not objective: a co-rotating pair of vortices occupies two per cent of a window to one observer and twenty-five to another.

kinematics · Coherent structures Five numbers, one flow, one name. A hyperbolic-tangent shear layer with a matching density profile, measured five ways, each of which appears in the literature as "the Richardson number". The minimum gradient value is what Miles' and Howard's theorem is about and is the only one the quarter belongs to. The bulk numbers depend on which thickness and which velocity difference were used; the depth-averaged one depends on how far from the layer the measurement extended, and grows without limit as it extends further.

Five numbers, one name

The Richardson number has a threshold at a quarter, and the quarter belongs to one of the five quantities that go by the name. On a single tanh shear layer they run from J to seventeen J, and the largest of them grows without limit as the measurement is extended further from the layer.

turbulence · Stratification The growth rate a discretised sheet has, at every wavelength it can carry. Kelvin–Helmholtz gives a growth rate proportional to the wavenumber and without bound. A sheet represented by N point vortices has pi m (1 − m/N) instead — the same rate at long waves and half of it at the shortest wave the grid carries, with the fastest-growing mode at the grid scale itself. Smoothing the kernel over a length delta moves that mode back to a wavelength the physics chose.

A sheet that cannot stay a sheet

Let a shear layer's thickness go to zero and it becomes a surface across which the velocity jumps. The model is used everywhere in this subject, it is unstable at every wavelength, and the thing it does next is worse: it develops a singularity in its own shape, at a finite time, from a smooth start.

inviscid · Vortex sheet Every unstable mode of every profile, inside one circle. The complex phase speeds of the unstable modes, scaled so that each profile's own semicircle is the unit one. Howard's theorem says every one of them must lie inside — the centre and the radius are the mean and half-range of the velocity profile and nothing else — and every one of them does, with the closest approach at 0.915 of the radius.

Every unstable wave is inside one circle

Before solving anything, you know where the answer is. Howard's theorem says the complex phase speed of any growing disturbance in a shear flow lies inside a circle fixed by the fastest and slowest parts of the profile — and by nothing else about it at all.

turbulence · Instability Instability up to a quarter, and none past it. The fastest growth rate of a stratified shear layer against its Richardson number, on a profile whose gradient Richardson number is the same at every height. It falls smoothly towards zero and reaches it at a quarter: at Ri = 0.2499 the fastest mode still grows at 0.00106, and at 0.26 the solver finds no unstable mode at all.

Sufficient, and not necessary

A stratified shear layer whose Richardson number exceeds a quarter everywhere cannot go unstable. That is a theorem with an exact number in it. What it does not say — and what it is constantly read as saying — is that a layer below a quarter will.

turbulence · Stratification A window one core wide reads the vortex 7.5 per cent slow. The tangential velocity across a Lamb–Oseen vortex, in units of its core radius and of Γ/2π divided by it, as it is and as particle image velocimetry reports it with square interrogation windows of three widths — the average of the velocity over each window, which is what a correlation over the window returns to first order. The true peak is 0.6382 at 1.1209 core radii. A window 0.5 core radii wide reports 98.0 per cent of it, 1.021 times as far out, a window 1 core radii wide reports 92.5 per cent of it, 1.084 times as far out and a window 2 core radii wide reports 77.1 per cent of it, 1.334 times as far out. The instrument that measures velocity directly still reports a slower, fatter vortex than the one there, by an amount set entirely by the window against the core.

The window every vector is averaged over

Particle image velocimetry is the one flow-visualisation technique that reports the velocity itself, and it still applies an operator: every vector is an average over an interrogation window. A window is a filter with a transfer function, and it makes a vortex slower and fatter, a thin shear layer exactly as thick as the window, and some features smaller than the window point the wrong way.

misconceptions · Visualisation A vortex sheet rolling up, at five stages. One period of an initially flat vortex sheet with a small perturbation on it, drawn at equal intervals. The perturbation grows, the sheet steepens, and the ends wind into a spiral. Nothing is added to the sheet after the first instant.

A spiral is a legible record

When a vortex sheet rolls up, the fluid in it can never change places: two points on a sheet cannot pass one another. So the arms of the spiral are a map of the initial sheet, in order, and the picture is a record of the roll-up rather than a snapshot of it.

inviscid · Vortex sheet

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

MeasurementInflection pointLinear stabilityModel limitVorticityCirculationMixingVortex sheetEigenvalueIll-posedKelvin helmholtzModel validity

All concepts