Concept

Buoyancy — where it appears

The force on a body or a parcel arising from a density difference in a gravitational field. It drives convection, it decides whether a grain is lifted from a bed, and stratification is the case where it opposes a parcel's displacement rather than assisting it.

Named by 15 essays across 5 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

Every disturbance has its own threshold; one of them is lowest. The Rayleigh number at which a disturbance of horizontal wavenumber a becomes neutral, Ra = (π² + a²)³/a². Every wavenumber has a threshold and the layer goes unstable at the lowest of them, which a golden-section search on this curve puts at a = 2.221441 and Ra = 657.5114 — the exact π/√2 and 27π⁴/4 to fourteen digits. Below the curve the layer conducts and nothing moves.

A threshold with a closed form

A layer of fluid heated from below sits still until buoyancy overcomes both diffusions at once, and then it convects. Unlike every other threshold in this field, that one is an eigenvalue with an exact answer, and the answer is 27π⁴/4.

turbulence · Convection
The relaxation time a particle actually has. Two quantities against the particle-to-fluid density ratio. β = 3ρ_f/(2ρ_p + ρ_f) is three for a bubble, one for a neutrally buoyant particle and nearly zero for anything heavy; it is the factor by which the fluid's own acceleration is felt. The other curve is the true relaxation time over the usual formula's, which is one for a heavy droplet, exactly three halves for a neutrally buoyant tracer, and unbounded for a bubble — the usual formula gives a bubble a relaxation time of zero, and therefore no dynamics at all.

The tracer that is not one

Every Stokes number is built on a relaxation time that counts the particle's own inertia and nothing else. Adding the two terms it leaves out gives a bubble a relaxation time where the usual formula gives zero, makes a neutrally buoyant tracer half as slow again as advertised, and sends bubbles into vortex cores that droplets are flung out of.

regimes · Particle
The pressure drop stops rising at 0.213 m/s. The pressure drop across a bed of 500 µm sand, against the velocity through it, in units of the fluidisation velocity. The rising branch is Ergun's resistance and the flat one is the bed's buoyant weight, which the flow cannot exceed however hard it is pushed: past the corner the bed expands rather than resisting more. That flat line is the reason fluidisation is unmistakable in practice — the corner is a crossing of two curves rather than a gradual departure, and it can be read off a gauge.

The bed that weighs itself

Blow hard enough through a pile of sand and the pressure drop stops rising. It cannot rise — a control volume round the bed says the drop can never exceed the buoyant weight of the solid in it, and at the velocity where the two meet the bed stops being a structure and starts being a fluid.

applied · Porous
Nu/Gr^¼ against the Prandtl number, with the exact solution's points on it. The closed form 0.508 Pr^½(20/21 + Pr)^−¼, over eight decades, with Ostrach's exact similarity values marked. The integral method is two to eight per cent high from Pr = 0.7 upwards and 10 per cent low at Pr = 0.01 — which is where the thermal layer is ten times the momentum layer and giving them one thickness stops being an approximation to anything.

A speed nobody imposed

Every regime number in this collection contains a velocity somebody chose. Natural convection has none: a warm plate makes its own flow, and the Grashof number is what is left when the speed is taken out. The Reynolds number of the result — six thousand, on an ordinary radiator — is an output of the solution rather than a setting on an apparatus.

regimes · Grashof
Instability up to a quarter, and none past it. The fastest growth rate of a stratified shear layer against its Richardson number, on a profile whose gradient Richardson number is the same at every height. It falls smoothly towards zero and reaches it at a quarter: at Ri = 0.2499 the fastest mode still grows at 0.00106, and at 0.26 the solver finds no unstable mode at all.

Sufficient, and not necessary

A stratified shear layer whose Richardson number exceeds a quarter everywhere cannot go unstable. That is a theorem with an exact number in it. What it does not say — and what it is constantly read as saying — is that a layer below a quarter will.

turbulence · Stratification
The same wavelength drawn as rolls and as hexagons. Plan views of a convecting layer with one critical wavelength, drawn from the amplitude equations' two stable states. On the left, rolls: a single set of parallel bands, rising fluid along one set of lines and sinking along the next. On the right, hexagons: three sets of rolls at 120° to each other with equal amplitudes, whose sum has its maxima on a triangular lattice with spacing 2/√3 of the wavelength, each maximum at the centre of a hexagonal cell. At ε = 0.0250, inside the window, both are stable: rolls with amplitude 0.158 and hexagons with 0.081 in each of their three rolls. A hexagon is not a different kind of cell; it is three roll patterns that the quadratic term lets reinforce one another.

Hexagons remember how the heat was turned up

A layer heated from below convects in rolls, unless its top and bottom are not mirror images of each other. Then three sets of rolls at 120° can feed one another through a term the symmetry used to forbid, hexagonal cells appear before the layer is formally unstable, and there is a range of heating in which rolls and hexagons are both stable — so the pattern a layer shows depends on whether the heat was turned up or down to get there.

turbulence · Convection
The drip spacing is set by the depth of the layer. The spacing of the fastest-growing wave, in units of 2π capillary lengths, against the depth of the hanging layer in capillary lengths, for water, glycerol and honey. A thin film of any of them drips at √2. Deep water drips at √3. Deep glycerol and honey keep growing past √3, their fastest wave as long as the layer is deep, because viscosity slows short waves more than long ones.

How far apart a ceiling drips

A layer of liquid hanging from a ceiling is heavy fluid over light, and every ripple on it longer than about seventeen millimetres grows. Which ripple grows fastest, and so how far apart the drips form, is usually given as one number. It is at least three, and what chooses between them is not the liquid's surface tension but the depth of the layer.

turbulence · Instability
Whether a sloping ceiling drips in place is one ray's growth. How fast a disturbance grows as seen by an observer moving along the ceiling at speed v, for four speeds at which the film carries its disturbances downhill, in the film's own units. On a flat ceiling (V = 0) the growth peaks at a quarter for the observer standing still and falls to zero for one running at ±1.622. Tilting the ceiling slides the whole curve downhill. While the observer at the point disturbed, v = 0, still sees growth, the ceiling drips where the disturbance began; at V = 1.622 that observer sees none, and above it the disturbance grows only while it is carried away.

A sloping ceiling drips downhill, or not at all

A film hanging from a level ceiling drips where its ripples form. Tilt the ceiling and the film flows downhill, carrying its ripples with it, and at some slope they are carried away faster than they spread and the ceiling stops dripping in place. That slope is set by one number, 1.622 — the speed at which a level ceiling's disturbance spreads — and for water it is tiny: a degree for a tenth of a millimetre of film, six for half a millimetre. Past it the ripples still grow, and still drip, but downhill, at a distance that grows with the slope: a ceiling shorter than that delivers its water to the edge.

turbulence · Instability
A thin interface stays unstable far past a quarter. The fastest growth rate of any disturbance against the bulk Richardson number J, on a logarithmic scale, for a density interface as thick as the shear and two, two and a half and three times thinner. The matched layer's billow dies at a quarter, as Miles' theorem requires. Two times thinner, the billow dies sooner, its last growth at J = 0.12, and nothing replaces it. Three times thinner, the billow's last is at 0.08 and a travelling wave takes over: 0.0335 at a quarter, 0.0109 at one and 0.00629 at 1.3, falling steadily with no threshold in the range solved. At 2.5 the waves are weaker and reach 0.001 at 1.3.

A thin interface keeps its waves past a quarter

Miles' quarter rules a shear layer whose density changes over the same depth as its velocity. Make the density interface three times thinner and the stationary billow dies early, but a pair of travelling waves takes its place and is still growing at five times the quarter. No theorem is broken: at the edges of the shear, where the waves draw their energy, the local Richardson number has fallen to nothing.

turbulence · Stratification
Below 9.8 µm in silicone oil, a gradient of a degree per millimetre outruns gravity. The speed of a clean air bubble in 10 cSt silicone oil against its radius, on logarithmic axes: migrating in a gradient of 1 K/mm, which grows in proportion to the radius, and rising under its weight, which grows with its square. They cross at 9.81 µm and 31 µm/s. The crossing radius, 3|dσ/dT|G/(2ρg), has no viscosity in it: both speeds are set against the same viscous drag.

The warm side pulls a bubble with no force on it

A bubble in a liquid whose temperature varies from place to place moves towards the warm side, with no gravity and nothing pushing it. The surface tension is lower where the liquid is warmer, the surface is pulled towards the cold pole, and the bubble goes the other way. Young, Goldstein and Block's speed comes out of four interface conditions and one more: that the total force on the bubble is zero. That one condition removes the point force a sinking or rising body always carries, so the bubble's disturbance dies a hundred times faster with distance, and the radius at which it balances its own buoyancy has no viscosity in it.

viscous · Mobile interface
Each collapsed form of the plate's heat transfer reaches its limit decades away from air. The exact local Nusselt number of a vertical isothermal plate in its two collapsed forms against the Prandtl number: over (Gr·Pr²)^¼, which tends to Le Fevre's 0.600 as Pr → 0, and over (Gr·Pr)^¼, which tends to 0.503 as Pr → ∞. At Pr = 10⁻⁵ the first reads 0.5994; at 10⁵ the second reads 0.5023. The two limit laws cross at Pr = 0.494, where the exact value is 0.736 of either; air, at 0.72, reads 0.421 and 0.387.

Over a plate in mercury the warm layer flows as if inviscid

The exact solution for a warm vertical plate has been tabulated since 1953 and is usually shot from the wall, which fails in a liquid metal unless the shot starts within a thousandth of the answer. Posed instead as one algebraic system, it solves from a Prandtl number of a hundred-thousandth to a hundred thousand — and shows that in mercury the layer's speed is set without viscosity, that the integral method runs low there rather than high, and that air sits where neither limiting law is within a fifth.

regimes · Grashof
In stable air a wide-body's wake sinks a few hundred metres and stops tens of kilometres behind it. The depth the trailing vortex pair of a wide-body airliner has sunk, against distance behind the aeroplane, for buoyancy frequencies of 0.005, 0.01 and 0.02 per second and in neutral air: weight 3 MN, span 60 m, 250 m/s, air density 0.4 kg/m³, so the pair starts down at 2.15 m/s. It stops 638, 319 and 160 m down, 117, 58.3 and 29.2 km behind; in neutral air it would go on sinking.

Stable air takes back the momentum a wing pushes down

Behind a wing in neutral air the trailing vortices carry the downward momentum the wing gave the air for ever, and a face across the wake keeps its share of the weight however far back it is drawn. In stably stratified air the column the pair carries down is lighter than the air around it, and buoyancy pushes back. The pair stops a few hundred metres down, its momentum returned, after a time that is the same for every aeroplane — 2.33 divided by the buoyancy frequency, about four minutes — and from there on the whole weight crosses the box's upper and lower faces as pressure.

misconceptions · Momentum lift
A flat plate's layer is pushed along by the pressure its own warmth leaves, strongest at the wall. Across the layer of a horizontal plate warm side up, in air: the velocity scaled to its peak, the temperature excess, and the along-plate push −∂p′/∂x scaled to its wall value, against the similarity distance η = (y/x)·Gr^⅕. The push is the hydrostatic deficit under the warm fluid, (2/5)(ηθ − P), 0.694 at the wall in units of gβΔT·Gr^−⅕, falling to nothing at the layer's edge; the velocity peaks at η = 1.58 and the warm layer ends near 5.93.

Laid flat, a warm plate is pushed by the pressure of its own layer

A warm vertical plate drives its layer with buoyancy acting along it. Lay the plate flat and buoyancy acts across the layer instead, so the only push along it is the pressure deficit its own warm fluid leaves under the cold — deeper where the layer is thicker. That push gives a heat transfer growing as the fifth root of the Grashof number, not the fourth, works only on the plate's upper face, and survives a tilt of a degree for a third of a metre.

regimes · Grashof
Of the four common plumes, only the laminar one above a line speeds up as it rises. Centreline speed against height for four plumes, each scaled to its own speed at one reference height: laminar above a line source, rising as the fifth root of height; laminar above a point source and turbulent above a line, both constant; and turbulent above a point, falling as height to the minus one third. Each exponent follows from the heat flux being fixed and the width growing by diffusion, √(νx/u), when laminar, or in proportion to height when turbulent.

Above a warm wire the plume speeds up as it rises

A plume above a line of heat has no wall, no imposed speed and one conserved quantity, the heat it carries. That alone fixes a centreline speed growing as the fifth root of height — the only one of the four common plumes that accelerates — a temperature excess falling as the three-fifths power, and a warm core that is narrower than the moving sheet around it in any fluid more viscous than five ninths of its own diffusivity. At that Prandtl number the equations have a closed form, and the solver lands on it to three parts in a million.

regimes · Grashof
An oval that sheds its fluid is braked less, so the pair sinks further and stops later, until it sheds too fast to stop at all. The depth of a trailing vortex pair below its starting level, in spacings, against time in spacings over its initial speed, in air of N = 0.22: Saffman's oval, which keeps its fluid, and one detraining with α = 0.05. Saffman's stops at depth 6.75 after 10.6; this one at 6.93 after 12.4.

A wake that sheds its fluid sinks further, and past a point does not stop

In stable air the pair of trailing vortices behind a wing carries a column of lighter air down with it, and buoyancy pushes the column back until the pair has given up its momentum and stops. That picture keeps every parcel of the column. A real pair sheds the light air as it sinks, and shedding does two things at once: it takes away part of the momentum the buoyancy had to return, and it takes away the buoyancy that was returning it. The second wins. A pair that sheds a little stops later and deeper; one that sheds faster than a threshold loses its column before buoyancy can stop it. The shed air keeps a quarter of the momentum swinging up and down behind the aeroplane.

misconceptions · Momentum lift

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Model limitLinear stabilityEigenvalueHeat transferMeasurementPrandtl numberSimilarity solutionStratificationSurface tensionBoundary layerRegimeThreshold

All concepts