Model validity — where it appears
Named by 69 essays across 9 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.
The theory that solves everything
Throw away viscosity and assume nothing is spinning, and fluid mechanics collapses into a linear problem with closed-form answers. The price is one term, and the term turns out to matter more than everything kept.
The two theories, side by side
The exact solution and the real flow, for the same body in the same stream. One is beautiful and predicts nothing has drag; the other is approximate and has a wake in it. Where they agree and where they part is the whole map of the subject.
The roughness a wall cannot feel
A rough pipe and a polished one carry the same flow for the same pressure over three decades of Reynolds number, and then suddenly they do not. What changed is not the pipe. It is the thickness of the film of fluid at the wall, which is the only part of the flow that can see the roughness at all.
The world with no inertia
Drop the viscosity and the equations become exactly solvable and wrong about drag. Drop the inertia instead and they become exactly solvable again — and for a cylinder in an unbounded fluid there is no solution at all, which took fifty years to notice and longer to fix.
When the wedge is too blunt
Every curve of shock angle against deflection has a maximum. Past it there is no attached shock at any angle — the solver has no root to return and must say so, rather than quietly handing back the nearest thing and drawing a picture that cannot exist.
An hour for every tenfold
Turbulence is deterministic and unpredictable, and the exchange rate between those two is exact: measuring the initial state ten times better buys the same extra forecast time every time, for ever. A constant, and it belongs to the flow rather than to the instrument.
A right total from a wrong picture
Newtonian impact theory has a free constant in it. Tuned at five degrees it reproduces a NACA 2412's lift exactly, and no measurement at five degrees can tell it from the truth. What separates them is the derivative — a lift-curve slope 2.8 times too steep — which is a second constraint rather than a better one.
Drag in the theory that forbids it
d'Alembert's paradox is a theorem about flows that close behind the body. Stop requiring that, let two streamlines leave the edges and never come back, and the same equations — no viscosity, no vorticity — produce a drag coefficient of 0.8798.
A calculation with no memory in it
The bee calculation is famous for using the wrong velocity. Done with the right one it still falls short, and the reason is structural: a quasi-steady sum is a statement about a wing that has always been going, and an insect's wing travels between two and five chord lengths before it turns round.
The shutter is part of the answer
Flow photographs are compared as though the exposure were a detail of the camera. It is a term in the measurement: an average over exactly one shedding period returns the true mean to fourteen figures, any other length carries a residue that falls only as one over the exposure, and a two-pulse velocity reading is short by exactly the sinc of the swept angle.
The same statistics, and a different load
A wind or wave specification is written as a spectrum, and a spectrum discards the phases. Two records built from one spectrum agree in variance to thirteen figures and in peak drag load by twenty per cent — and with the phases lined up, the same spectrum is a single impulse thirty-one times worse.
The bath that was only ever a wait
The Coriolis force is far too weak to steer a draining bath, and it does steer a large enough tank that has been left alone long enough. Both are true, and the number that separates them is not a force ratio — it is how many turns the earth's contribution gets through before the vessel is empty.
The vorticity nothing decides
A streamline that comes from upstream carries its vorticity with it. A closed one comes from nowhere, so nothing determines what it carries — the ambiguity is not one number per body but a whole function. What closes it is a limit, and setting the viscosity to zero gives a different answer from letting it go to zero.
The exact theory, drawn by viscosity
Two flat plates a millimetre apart, syrup between them, an obstacle in the gap. The Reynolds number is a hundredth, inertia is absent, and the streamline pattern is the potential flow past that obstacle — exactly, to a part in ten billion. The one hypothesis ideal flow cannot do without is the one this flow most conspicuously breaks.
A solid, if it is not given time
The Deborah number is the only group on this site with no fluid in it — two times and nothing else — and it says a material is a solid or a liquid depending on how long anybody watches. What it throws away is that no real material has one time, and the spectrum it replaces changes the answer in kind rather than in degree.
A number that is only the shape of the hole
The friction factor times the Reynolds number for laminar flow in a duct is a pure number that depends on the cross-section's shape and on nothing else — not the fluid, not the size, not the flow rate. It is exactly 64 for a circle and exactly 96 for a slot, and the correlation that treats them as the same is wrong by a third.
The drift a closed box will not allow
A wave in a wave tank carries mass forward, and the tank has nowhere to put it. So a return current appears carrying exactly the opposite transport — exactly, from mass conservation and nothing else. Which fixes a total and leaves the answer anybody wants entirely open.
Two strainings, and the order they came in
A material line is stretched by a shear and then by a pure strain, and then by the same two in the other order. Every instantaneous measure of how hard the fluid was being worked is identical in the two cases. The lengths at the end differ by a factor of 2.16.
A scalar is a record of where its fluid was
A conserved scalar has no value of its own. Its value at a point is whatever it was at the place that point's fluid started from, which makes a dye field a photograph of the past — and makes the map from now to then the only thing in the flow that carries the past at all.
Sufficient, and not necessary
A stratified shear layer whose Richardson number exceeds a quarter everywhere cannot go unstable. That is a theorem with an exact number in it. What it does not say — and what it is constantly read as saying — is that a layer below a quarter will.
A drift made of two things that average to zero
Stokes drift is usually explained as a parcel spending longer in the forward half of its orbit. That is true and it is not a formula. The formula is a correlation between a displacement and a gradient, each of which averages to exactly nothing, and it splits into two halves that are equal to twelve figures.
Equal on average, and nothing else
The rate at which a fluid turns motion into heat can be written two ways, and every textbook says the two are equivalent. Their averages are equal to fourteen decimal places. Point by point they are uncorrelated, and their maxima are in different places.
A boundary that only exists over a window
The curve that separates fluid going one way from fluid going another is not in any snapshot of the flow. It is the crest of a field built from a stretch of history, it moves when the stretch is changed, and reversing the direction of time gives a different curve entirely — both of them real.
A gas that has not finished being shocked
The jump conditions give the state a long way behind a shock. Immediately behind it the molecules have not started vibrating yet, so the temperature is 2,382 K where the equilibrium answer is 2,059 — and the gas takes four tenths of a millimetre to get from one to the other.
A threshold that is also a duration
The cavitation number treats inception as a pressure: below it the liquid tears, above it does not. A five-micron bubble asked to grow in 0.3 microseconds needs 43 bar of tension and the same bubble given a hundred needs 1.05, because it has to make a journey and not merely respond.
What a mean profile cannot tell anybody
Two flows are built here with mean velocity profiles that agree to four parts in 10¹⁷. One of them carries momentum across the shear and dissipates forty per cent more energy; the other carries nothing. Everything that distinguishes them is second order in a disturbance the mean cannot see at all.
A surface that remembers the diaphragm
Between the shock and the expansion in a shock tube there is a surface across which the pressure and the velocity are identical and the temperature differs by a factor of two. It is made of fluid, so it never goes away, and nothing in the pressure field says it is there.
The ball that never forgets its spin
Commentary explains a late-swerving ball by saying the spin is dying away. The spin-down torque goes as speed times spin, so spin decays over a distance rather than a time — 1,202 metres for a golf ball against a 200-metre drive — and what dies away is the speed, which makes the swerve stronger.
Where the line stops being a line
Prandtl's lifting line replaces a wing with a single bound vortex and its trailing sheet, and the formula that comes out is the most quoted in low-speed aerodynamics. Solved numerically at aspect ratio one it returns its own closed form to sixteen decimals — and the answer is forty-one per cent too high.
The core that does not move
Toothpaste in a tube has a region in the middle that is not being sheared at all, and its edge is at a radius you can write down before solving anything. Four things about that core are exact, and one of them is that the fluid does not flow below a threshold — not slowly, at all.
How long the fluid has been in there
Age is the simplest thing a flow can remember. It obeys the shortest transport equation in the subject — its material derivative is one — and no instrument pointed at a steady flow can read it, because a steady flow's every field is constant and its fluid is getting older all the time.
The sound now is the source then
Every acoustic calculation is an exercise in bookkeeping about when. The pressure arriving at a listener was emitted at an earlier time, at a place the source has since left, and the Doppler shift is not a separate effect at all — it is the slope of the curve relating the two.
A puff that does not know how old it is
A patch of turbulence in a pipe below the critical Reynolds number dies at random, and its chance of dying in the next second does not depend on how long it has already lasted. The flow that contains it has a memory anyway, because the patches multiply — and where multiplying overtakes dying is a Reynolds number.
A duct that cannot be run backwards
Friction drives a compressible duct flow towards the speed of sound from either side, and the entropy rises the whole way. So the state of the gas at a station is an odometer: it records how much duct is behind it, and no amount of further duct can take it back.
Exactly similar, and one number short
The round jet has an exact solution of the Navier–Stokes equations, and a turbulent jet is modelled by the same formula with the viscosity replaced by a fitted constant. The shape is identical. Nothing a measurement of the profile can do will tell the two apart.
How far downwind a surface is remembered
Walk from a field into a wood and the wind ten metres above your head is still the field's wind. It takes about a kilometre of trees before a ten-metre measurement is measuring the trees — a hundred times the height it is made at, and a great deal more than most masts are given.
A gas that has not decided to react yet
Behind a detonation's leading shock there is a zone in which nothing measurable happens. Its length is set by the temperature the shock produced, exponentially — a one per cent change in the shock shortens it by fifteen per cent — and that sensitivity is why a detonation front cannot stay flat.
A dissipation that lags its production
Change the strain rate on a patch of turbulence and the production of energy follows instantly — it is the strain squared. The dissipation moves by less than one per cent, because it is the far end of a cascade that has not been told yet, and the two are out of balance by a factor of six for the next turnover.
Two totals, one of which a shock cannot touch
Across a normal shock the total temperature ratio is 1.000000000000000 at every Mach number, and the total pressure ratio falls to 0.0085 by Mach 8. One of the two records the energy that has been added to the gas and nothing else; the other records every irreversibility on the way.
A closure with no memory at all
An eddy viscosity says the Reynolds stress is the mean strain rate times a number, now. The stress it is standing in for takes a turnover to arrive, so the closure is the zero-frequency limit of a response that has a lag in it — and the curve it is the limit of is the same shape as an aerofoil's lift deficiency.
The drag that integrates a whole history
A particle released in still air does not stop exponentially. The unsteady drag on it carries a term that is an integral over everything the particle has already done, weighted by the inverse square root of how long ago — so there is no time constant, and five particle time constants later it is still moving four times faster than the quasi-steady answer allows.
A dissipation correlated across every scale
The dissipation is supposed to be the most local quantity in turbulence — a thing happening at the smallest eddies, everywhere and independently. A multiplicative cascade makes its logarithm correlated over a distance that is a ratio of logarithms, so two points a thousand smallest scales apart still agree a quarter of the time.
Two forces, and only one of them remembers
Morison's equation adds an inertia term to a drag term and is usually presented as an empirical patch. It is not: the two terms are the two kinds of memory this collection has been separating, one a function of the present acceleration and one a function of the wake left by the previous half cycle.
The wall the fluid is listening to
Water two millimetres above a moving wall is responding to what the wall did two thirds of a second ago — most likely. Half of its response is older than four and a half seconds, a tenth is older than two minutes, and the average age of what it is responding to does not exist at all.
A wake that keeps the drag and forgets the body
Two very different wakes with the same momentum deficit converge to the same profile, because the deficit is conserved and everything else diffuses away. The convergence is a power law rather than an exponential, so it takes two hundred widths for twenty per cent agreement and nine hundred for five.
The state a machine was started into
Above the critical driving there is not one flow but a band of them, and a container of a given size can hold several. Which one appears is decided by how the apparatus was brought up to speed, and at twice critical there are eight to choose from.
The fluid that has not finished its last deformation
Shear a polymer solution for two seconds and stop. Nothing is moving and the fluid is still stressed — 37 per cent of the peak one relaxation time later, and still measurably stressed after five. Two histories imposing exactly the same total strain leave it in states differing by a factor of 3.7.
A wake told what to do
Force a shedding wake near its own frequency and it abandons its own and adopts the forcing's. The band over which it will do so is proportional to how hard it is pushed — and near the edge of the band it takes six times as long to make up its mind.
The truncation that cannot carry three times the heat
Lorenz's three modes give a convecting layer's heat flux in one line — one plus twice (r − 1) over r — and it can never reach three times what conduction carries. The same rolls computed with forty-two modes agree with that line exactly at onset, carry 7.1 per cent more heat at twice the critical Rayleigh number, and twice as much at thirty times it. The ceiling is not in the convection; it is in having one sine to draw the temperature with.
The lag that makes flutter possible
This site's own flutter model set the lift deficiency to one and recorded in its notes that doing so throws away the lag which stabilises the torsion mode. Putting the lag back moves the flutter speed from 80.8 metres a second to 131, and removes the need for the structural damping that was covering the artefact.
A layer that is an integral of everything upstream
Two surfaces are given external velocity distributions that agree exactly at one station — the same speed and the same gradient. The boundary layers there differ by 38 per cent in momentum thickness, and the two surfaces separate five per cent of their length apart.
Slip is a memory of one mean free path
A molecule arriving at a wall last collided about a mean free path away and carries the velocity from there. Averaged over arrivals and departures, that leaves the gas at the wall moving — by two per cent of the centreline speed at a Knudsen number of a hundredth, and sixty per cent more flow through a microchannel at a tenth.
A cone finishes its turn after the shock
A wedge turns a supersonic stream all at once, at its shock. A cone of the same angle does not: its shock turns the flow only part of the way and leaves the rest to a smooth compression between the shock and the surface. Solved from Taylor and Maccoll's equation, the cone's shock is weaker, keeps more of the total pressure, carries less than half the wedge's surface pressure, and stays attached to 40.7° at Mach 2 where the wedge gives up at 23°.
The drift was the instrument
Kelvin's theorem was checked on this site by carrying a loop and watching its circulation move by eight parts in a hundred thousand. That drift is not the flow forgetting. The exact number is a count of what is inside the loop, it does not move by anything at all, and the drift belongs entirely to the two instruments used to measure it.
Two lifts at one incidence
A wing pitched up and down through the stall does not retrace its own lift curve. At twelve degrees it carries 0.22 more lift going up than coming down, and the loop that opens between the two is the work the airstream does on it — which is where the energy for a stall flutter comes from.
How long a fluid takes to forget it was not rotating
Spin a container of water and the fluid inside reaches solid-body rotation in a hundred seconds rather than the three hours diffusion would need. The shortcut is the thin layers on the end walls, and the advantage they give is exactly the reciprocal of the square root of the Ekman number.
A particle is a low-pass filter
A seeding particle does not report the flow; it reports the flow through its own transfer function. At a Stokes number of one it follows 71 per cent of the motion and lags it by 45 degrees, and a fifty-micron droplet at a kilohertz is following two per cent of what it is supposed to be measuring.
The drift a rotating planet takes back
In a wave tank the Stokes drift is cancelled by a return current because the tank has walls. The open ocean has none, and the drift is cancelled anyway: the Coriolis force acts on the water's real motion, drives an Eulerian current that answers it, and leaves the depth-integrated transport exactly zero at every viscosity. A float under steady swell with nothing to stop it goes round a circle instead of away.
A spiral is a legible record
When a vortex sheet rolls up, the fluid in it can never change places: two points on a sheet cannot pass one another. So the arms of the spiral are a map of the initial sheet, in order, and the picture is a record of the roll-up rather than a snapshot of it.
A wake that says what made it
Two vortices sitting behind an aeroplane carry its weight and its span in a form that can be read back out: circulation times separation times density times speed is the lift, exactly. The reading is exact for about a minute and worth nothing after four.
A duct that forgets everything but one number
Whatever is fed into a pipe, what survives a little way down it is one shape. The disturbance's higher modes decay as the square of their mode number, so the sixth is gone in thirteen centimetres where the first survives four and a half metres — and the entrance length is that one mode's decay rate and an arbitrary threshold.
Every memory number is one time over another
These essays produced eight dimensionless groups in eight different fields, named after eight different people, spanning a factor of four hundred in value. Written out, all eight are a memory time divided by a process time, and all eight govern the same curve.
Reversible, and unusable
Ideal flow has no arrow of time in it. Run a stirring backwards and the dye comes back — here to 1.4 parts in a thousand million. Nudge the state by a hundred-millionth first and the same reversal returns a blob almost five hundred times further from home than the nudge was large.
A blade that flies through what it shed
A rotor blade meets the tip vortex the blade in front of it left, a fifth of a second earlier, at a few per cent of the radius. What it feels is a doublet — five and a half degrees of upwash and then five and a half of downwash within a few chords — and the peak goes as one over the miss distance.
Everything about the start, except one vector
Six ways of accelerating a body from rest to the same speed produce six force histories with nothing in common — peaks spanning a factor of thirty-nine, two of them negative for part of the journey. The impulse left in the fluid is the same ten-figure number in every case, and so is the energy.
A row that meets the row before it
A compressor blade is loaded and unloaded thirty times a revolution by geometry it does not have. The forcing sits at the blade count of the row in front of it and at multiples of that, and how far up the harmonics it reaches is decided by how far apart the two rows are.
Nothing in the present picks the flow
Six flows past one cylinder satisfy the same equation and let nothing through the wall, to the last bit of double precision. Their lifts run from zero to 37.7 and their peak suctions differ by a factor of twenty-one. The equations do not choose between them, and the thing that does is the history.
The inflow that takes time to arrive
Momentum theory gives a rotor's induced velocity from its thrust, instantly. It does not arrive instantly: the air the disc has to accelerate has a mass, and the response is a first-order climb with a time constant of 33 milliseconds — a twentieth of the time the wake itself takes to convect a radius.
The theory with no memory in it
Laplace's equation has no time in it, so an ideal flow's response to a body being jerked into motion is instantaneous and complete. Its indicial kernel is a spike and nothing afterwards. Beside it sit the two kernels that are not, and the comparison says which ingredient every memory in this collection came in through.
Named alongside it
The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.
MeasurementMemory kernelRegimeRelaxation timeConvolutionWakeCirculationConserved quantityTransportBoundary conditionConvergenceMixing