Fluid Flow & Aerodynamics
why things fly, and why the usual explanation is wrong
Concept

Cancellation — where it appears

The near-exact cancellation, at a distance, of the fields of neighbouring sources of opposite sign. It is what makes a dipole or a quadrupole radiate so much less than its parts, and each order of it costs one power of the source's size against the wavelength.

Named by 2 essays across one field — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

Also named here as compactness — the same set of essays touches all of them, so they are one junction rather than several.

The sound is what fails to cancel. A compact quadrupole of kd = 0.01, followed outwards. The upper curve is what one of its four sources produces on its own at each radius — every one of them is as loud as a monopole — and the lower curve is what all four produce together. Inside the source they barely cancel at all; by one radian of wavelength the sum is 9.3e-5 of what a single source is doing, and it is falling as 1/R from there on because that is what radiation does. Between the two the field falls as the cube of the distance, which is a near field rather than a sound.

The sound is what does not cancel

A quadrupole is not a weak source. Every one of the four monopoles in it is as loud as a monopole of the same strength, and what makes the assembly quiet is that they very nearly cancel — one part in ten thousand survives at a hundredth of a wavelength. The eighth-power law is a statement about how nearly, not about how little.

compressible · Aeroacoustics The body's dipole outshouts the flow's quadrupoles by one over the Mach number squared. The power of a wire's lift tone over the generous bound on its wake's quadrupole noise, against the wind's Mach number, for rms lift coefficients 0.2, 0.45 and 0.6 — the spread of the measurements. At Mach 0.03, a 10 m/s wind, the ratio is 9.4·10⁴; it falls as one over the Mach number squared and is still 104 at Mach 0.9, where a real cylinder's shedding has long since changed.

A wire sings with the force on it, not the flow round it

A free flow can only radiate as a quadrupole, four sources nearly cancelling, which is why a jet's noise grows as the eighth power of its speed and so little of its power becomes sound. Put a body in the flow and the cancellation is broken: the fluctuating force the body exerts is a dipole, its sound grows as the sixth power, and at the speed of any wind it outshouts the turbulence that made it by a factor of tens of thousands. The whistle of a wire is the force of its own wake, radiated.

compressible · Aeroacoustics

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

AeroacousticsCompactnessFar fieldMeasurementMultipoleSound powerAcoustic analogyAveragingCorrelationJetLighthill's acoustic analogyMach number

All concepts