Fluid Flow & Aerodynamics
why things fly, and why the usual explanation is wrong
Concept

Initial condition — where it appears

The state a flow is given at the moment a calculation or an experiment begins. Where a flow has a memory it is not forgotten: two flows in identical present conditions can differ permanently because they were started differently, which makes it part of the answer rather than a detail of the setup.

Named by 11 essays across 6 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

The one calculation in which the atmosphere really does push. How high a partial vacuum inside the tube will raise the liquid, against the absolute pressure achieved inside it. The lift is (p_atm − p_inside)/ρg and it is capped at the barometric height of 10.11 m, because below the vapour pressure the liquid boils and pulling harder buys nothing. The horizontal lines are five crown heights: a crown below a line's intersection with the curve can be primed by suction and one above it cannot, at any pump. This is the process the running siphon's argument explicitly excluded, and it is the one where the atmospheric account is the mechanism rather than a limit.

The one place the atmosphere pushes

The height of a siphon's hump is not in its flow rate, and the atmosphere holds the column together rather than driving it. That account excludes one process by name — starting. That is the process the atmospheric account describes correctly, and it is the only one in the whole device.

misconceptions · Siphon Two decay laws from two invariants, and nothing in the equations to choose. The energy of a decaying turbulence against time, integrated from dK/dt = −A K^(3/2)/l with the large scales conserving u² l³ in one case and u² l⁵ in the other. The exponents come out at 1.1997 and 1.4282 against the closed forms 6/5 and 10/7. Which invariant holds is decided by the shape of the spectrum at the very largest scales, at the moment the stirring stops.

What decay never forgets

Stir a box of fluid and stop. The turbulence decays, at a rate with no viscosity in it — so the rate cannot come from the fluid. It comes from an invariant of the very largest scales, fixed at the moment the stirring stops, and never revisited.

turbulence · Decay The source falls 6 m and the crown pressure does not move. The pressure at the crown of a draining siphon, against time, as the source level falls from the top of the tank to the end of the run, a drop of 6 m. It is flat to 1.5e-11 pascals — not nearly flat, exactly flat, because the two effects of a falling source cancel identically. Losing a metre of level shrinks the drop, which slows the flow and raises the crown pressure by half a velocity head; and it grows the rise, which lowers the crown pressure by ρg per metre. Those are the same number. So a siphon that starts will not break as it drains, however far the level falls, and the run ended because the level reached the outlet instead.

The siphon that does not break

A draining reservoir shrinks the drop and grows the rise at the same time, and the siphon's own coupling — a metre of extra drop costs a metre of hump — says a siphon should break as it empties. It does not. The two effects cancel exactly, and the crown pressure of a draining siphon is a constant that does not contain the source level at all.

misconceptions · Siphon Five points, and where each one's fluid came from. Back-trajectories through six units of time in an unsteady double gyre. Each curve ends at the place the fluid now at the marked point started; nothing about that place can be read off the velocity at the marker.

A scalar is a record of where its fluid was

A conserved scalar has no value of its own. Its value at a point is whatever it was at the place that point's fluid started from, which makes a dye field a photograph of the past — and makes the map from now to then the only thing in the flow that carries the past at all.

kinematics · Advection The line the dye actually draws. A streakline in an oscillating uniform stream: everything released from the origin over the last 3.4 units of time, drawn where it has got to at one instant. The parameter along it is release time, not distance and not time of flight, which is why it is a record rather than a curve of the field. The mean speed of 1 exceeds the amplitude of 0.6, so the fluid never reverses and the filament is single-valued in x.

The line the dye actually draws

The streakline is the curve most photographs really show, and of the three curves it is the hardest to compute, because it needs the whole history of the flow. This draws it, in a flow where all four curves have closed forms, and the third curve turns out to be a different kind of object from the other two rather than a third example of the same one.

kinematics · Flow curves A skin lags the air by a time its own thickness sets. A skin held at one flight condition, relaxing towards the adiabatic wall temperature. The approach is exponential with a time constant ρc τ / h — 8.37 s at 2 mm, 25.1 s at 6 mm, 50.2 s at 12 mm — so the temperature a steady recovery calculation gives is reached after several minutes rather than at once. The fluid supplies one number to this calculation, the adiabatic wall temperature, and the structure supplies everything else.

The skin that lags the flight

A wall can be told its temperature or told nothing, and both are solved problems. A real skin is told neither. It has heat capacity, so its temperature is a transient whose time constant is its own thickness divided by what the layer delivers — and the number the steady calculation returns is an upper bound a short exposure never collects.

compressible · Recovery The curve that lets in more than one answer. The neutral stability curve: the driving needed to sustain a disturbance of a given wavelength. It has a minimum, so at any driving above the minimum there is a whole band of wavelengths that can grow — and the system has to pick one.

The state a machine was started into

Above the critical driving there is not one flow but a band of them, and a container of a given size can hold several. Which one appears is decided by how the apparatus was brought up to speed, and at twice critical there are eight to choose from.

regimes · Taylor A vortex sheet rolling up, at five stages. One period of an initially flat vortex sheet with a small perturbation on it, drawn at equal intervals. The perturbation grows, the sheet steepens, and the ends wind into a spiral. Nothing is added to the sheet after the first instant.

A spiral is a legible record

When a vortex sheet rolls up, the fluid in it can never change places: two points on a sheet cannot pass one another. So the arms of the spiral are a map of the initial sheet, in order, and the picture is a record of the roll-up rather than a snapshot of it.

inviscid · Vortex sheet Five spectra, five exponents, one linear equation. The energy of a decaying turbulence after the nonlinear term has stopped mattering, computed by integrating the exact modal solution E(k,0)exp(−2 nu k² t) at five different shapes of the spectrum at the origin. Each is a straight line on these axes and no two have the same slope: the exponent is (m+1)/2, where k^m is the spectrum's behaviour at wavenumbers smaller than any eddy. The 5/2 that is quoted as the final period's universal exponent is the m = 4 line and one of five.

Universal, and one of five

A turbulence that has run its Reynolds number down stops being turbulent, the equations go linear, and the decay picks up a new exponent. That exponent is quoted everywhere as 5/2 and as universal. It is neither: it is the same corner of the same spectrum deciding the answer a second time.

turbulence · Decay There and back again. A blob of a hundred and twenty tracer particles at the start, after four time units of stirring, and after the same four run backwards. The third set is drawn over the first and the worst particle is 1.4·10⁻⁹ from where it began.

Reversible, and unusable

Ideal flow has no arrow of time in it. Run a stirring backwards and the dye comes back — here to 1.4 parts in a thousand million. Nudge the state by a hundred-millionth first and the same reversal returns a blob almost five hundred times further from home than the nudge was large.

inviscid · Vortex dynamics Six flows past one cylinder, all of them legal. The tangential speed on the surface for six values of the circulation. Every one of them solves the same equation and lets nothing through the wall; the fastest point on the surface runs from twice the free stream to eight times it.

Nothing in the present picks the flow

Six flows past one cylinder satisfy the same equation and let nothing through the wall, to the last bit of double precision. Their lifts run from zero to 37.7 and their peak suctions differ by a factor of twenty-one. The equations do not choose between them, and the thing that does is the history.

inviscid · Multiply-connected

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Memory kernelMeasurementModel limitModel validityFlow mapAbsolute pressureBarometric heightBoundary conditionCavitationCirculationDecayFinal period

All concepts