Fluid Flow & Aerodynamics
why things fly, and why the usual explanation is wrong
Concept

Murray's law — where it appears

The rule that a branching vessel is cheapest to run when the cube of the parent's radius equals the sum of the cubes of its daughters'. It balances the work of pushing a steady flow through narrow vessels against the cost of the blood that wide ones hold, and it is not the rule that passes a pulse.

Named by 3 essays across 2 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

Area-preserving in the aorta, Murray's cube in the small arteries. The branching exponent k, in r_parent^k = r₁^k + r₂^k, that makes one junction reflect least of the heart's pulse, against the parent artery's radius, for a symmetric split and for side branches a half and 0.15 of the continuing trunk. In the aorta, where the pulse is carried by inertia, the transparent rule is close to 2 — area preserved — whatever the asymmetry. In arteries under a millimetre, where viscosity carries it, it is 3: Murray's law, the rule for the cheapest steady flow, is exactly the rule that passes the pulse. Asymmetry moves the answer only in between.

Murray's law passes the pulse where the pulse is viscous

The rule that makes an arterial junction transparent to the heart's pulse was an exponent, and real arteries do not split evenly: the aorta sheds side branches a fraction of its size and carries on. For a lopsided junction the transparent rule is still an exponent — the same one, exactly, while viscosity is negligible. With viscosity it is a single function of the parent's Womersley number: close to area-preserving in the aorta, and exactly Murray's cube in arteries under a millimetre, where the pulse moves as the steady flow does. The asymmetry matters only in between, and a lopsided tree reflects far less than an even one.

regimes · Womersley Local transparency is the best tree only when the ends absorb. The root's reflection at the heart rate against the reflection at the tree's leaves, for the map tree, for the single exponent that is best at that leaf reflection, and for Murray's. With leaves that reflect nothing the map tree is the best of all, 0.035 against 0.0419: making every junction transparent is then the whole job. As the leaves start to reflect, the best single exponent pulls ahead, because it leaves its junctions slightly mismatched in the way that cancels the echo coming back from the ends; at a leaf reflection of 0.5 it reflects 0.0735 to the map tree's 0.13.

A tree transparent at every junction is not the quietest

The branching rule that lets a heart's pulse through one junction without reflection is set by that junction's Womersley number: area-preserving in the aorta, Murray's in the small arteries. Build a whole arterial tree that way, every junction at its own transparent rule, and it reflects more of the pulse than the best tree built to a single exponent. The single exponent wins by leaving its junctions slightly mismatched, in the way that cancels the echo from the tree's own ends — the trick an antireflection coating plays on light.

regimes · Womersley Past transition the cube law gives way to two and a half. The exponent k in Q ∝ r^k obeyed by the cheapest vessel, against that vessel's Reynolds number, for a smooth wall and for a wall with a millimetre of roughness. While the flow is laminar k is 3, Murray's law. Past transition it drops to 2.45 at Re = 2·10⁴ and 2.4 at 1.01·10⁷, near Blasius's 27/11 = 2.455. A fixed absolute roughness barely moves it, because the cheapest pipes for large flows are large and a millimetre is a small fraction of them.

The cheapest turbulent pipe follows two and a half, not three

Murray's cube law comes from Poiseuille's resistance, and it fails the moment the flow in a vessel turns turbulent. The same cost minimised with turbulent friction gives a flow that grows as the radius to the power 27/11 in a smooth pipe and 7/3 in a rough one. Murray's invariant, a wall shear the same in every vessel, goes with it, and so does the local rule that made the law credible as biology: a vessel that holds its shear at a set point is twice too wide.

applied · Branching

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Model limitBlood flowImpedanceOptimisationPulsatile flowReflectionWomersley numberBranchingFriction factorPipe flowRoughnessScaling

All concepts