Fluid Flow & Aerodynamics
why things fly, and why the usual explanation is wrong
Concept

Momentum theorem — where it appears

The statement that the force on whatever is inside a control volume equals the momentum flowing out of it. It gives a force without any reference to the surface it acts on, and it is how a thrust, a drag or a lift can be measured from a survey.

Named by 26 essays across 9 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

The tube widens because the air slows. The streamtube through an actuator disc at an induction factor of 0.333. The three radii are not drawn to taste: each is fixed by requiring the same mass to pass every station, and the slowest station is therefore the widest. The tube widening in front of a wind turbine is why some of the wind goes round it rather than through it, and it is the whole reason a disc cannot take everything.

The most a disc can take

A wind turbine cannot extract more than sixteen twenty-sevenths of the energy passing through the circle its blades sweep. That is not a limit on turbines — it is a limit on anything at all, and it follows from three conservation laws and no engineering.

applied · Actuator disc A control volume round an aerofoil. A rectangle drawn in the fluid around a lifting section. The arrows on the right-hand face show the downward velocity of the air leaving it, drawn to scale. Adding the momentum carried through all four faces to the pressure acting on them gives the force on whatever is inside, without the calculation ever going near the surface.

Air must be pushed down, and the usual sum is wrong

The momentum explanation of lift is the one physicists reach for, and it is right — a wing does hold itself up by throwing air downwards. The version usually given then does the accounting badly, and the face of the control volume it keeps turns out to carry the least of it.

misconceptions · Momentum lift Betz's ceiling, and the rotor that cannot reach it. The power coefficient of Glauert's optimum rotor against tip-speed ratio, with Betz's 16/27 drawn as the ceiling it is. The gap is wake rotation: a rotor that extracts power applies a torque, a torque leaves the wake spinning, and that rotational energy never reaches the shaft. It falls as the rotor is geared up and is never zero — which is why large wind turbines turn so slowly and yet have such fast tips.

The wake that has to spin

A rotor that takes power out of the wind must apply a torque to it, and a torque applied to air is angular momentum left behind. The axial theory has nowhere to put that energy, so Betz's ceiling is unreachable at every finite tip-speed ratio — and the gap is computable.

applied · Actuator disc The box, and the one thing assumed about it. The control volume across a sudden enlargement. Mass and momentum crossing the two ends are known exactly. The only modelling statement in the whole derivation is written on the annular step: the pressure there is taken to be the upstream pressure, because the fluid in the corner is nearly stationary. Measurement supports it well. Nothing else is assumed, and in particular nothing at all is assumed about the eddy that lives in that corner — which this figure therefore does not draw.

A loss with no viscosity in it

Where a pipe suddenly widens, energy is destroyed. The amount is exact, it has been known since 1766, and the derivation never mentions viscosity, Reynolds number or roughness — because momentum does not care where the energy went, only that it left.

applied · Internal flow Two depths, and a gap the model will not describe. The surface either side of a hydraulic jump at an arriving Froude number of 5.05. Both depths are exact consequences of the momentum balance. The distance between them is not: the shallow-water model has no length scale in it and cannot say how far the transition takes, so the region between the two levels is left blank and the six-depth rule of thumb beside it is somebody's measurement rather than this site's result.

The shock in a river

Shallow water is a gas whose ratio of specific heats is two. The white water below a weir is a shock wave, momentum is conserved across it exactly, energy is not, and one direction is forbidden for the same reason an expansion shock is forbidden — which makes the analogy exact to first order and wrong at the second.

applied · Open-channel The lift curve that made flight look impossible. Lift coefficient against incidence, by Newton's impact theory and by thin-aerofoil theory. One is quadratic in the angle and the other linear, so at small incidence — which is where aircraft fly — they differ by more than an order of magnitude. Newton's version says a wing large enough to carry a man would need an engine nobody could build, and for a century that arithmetic was taken as settling the question.

The theory that forbade flight

Newton treated air as a hail of particles that give up their normal momentum on impact, and got a lift coefficient of 2sin²α cos α. At five degrees that is a thirty-sixth of what a wing actually makes, and the quadratic is why powered flight looked arithmetically impossible for two centuries. The same formula is exact at Mach twenty.

misconceptions · Newtonian Every curved streamline has a pressure gradient across it. Twelve points in the flow past a cylinder, with the arrow at each showing the pressure gradient across the streamline. It points away from the centre of curvature everywhere, and its size is ρq²κ: the fluid is being pushed round a bend, and something has to do the pushing. Both sides are computed here and they share no arithmetic — one is Bernoulli's pressure differenced across the flow, the other is the turning rate of the velocity direction along it — and they agree to 6.7e-5. This is the whole content of the effect usually named after Coandă, and it is happening on every curved streamline of every flow.

The effect that explains nothing

A jet follows a curved wall and the wall feels a suction. Both are real, both are famous, and naming them after Coandă explains neither — what is happening is the normal component of Euler's equation, and it holds on every curved streamline in every flow.

misconceptions · Coanda Two triangles, and the work is the difference between them. The velocity triangles at inlet and outlet of a rotor at constant blade speed and constant axial velocity. The horizontal arrow is the blade speed; the arrow from the origin is the absolute velocity of the fluid; the arrow closing the triangle is what the blade sees. Euler's equation says the work is the blade speed times the change in the swirl component alone — the horizontal distance between the two upper corners, times U — and nothing else in the picture appears in it.

Work out of a change of swirl

The work a rotor does per unit mass is the blade speed times the change in swirl, and that is all of it — no blade shape, no pressure, no efficiency, no gas properties. It is the same equation for a pump, a compressor, a turbine and a fan, and it follows from angular momentum on a box with nothing assumed about the inside.

applied · Turbomachine The jet is 61.1% of the hole. Flow out of a slot in a plane wall, solved by Kirchhoff's free-streamline method. The outer curve is not a wall and not a guess: it is the streamline on which the pressure is ambient, and where it goes is part of the solution. It leaves the edge of the slot travelling straight down the wall and turns through ninety degrees, settling to a jet whose width is π/(π+2) = 0.6110 of the opening. Every streamline drawn is a level set of the streamfunction the conformal map supplies.

The hole that halves the flow

A jet leaving a sharp-edged hole is narrower than the hole, and by an amount that is not measured but computed. One geometry gives exactly one half from momentum alone; another gives exactly π/(π+2) from a conformal map in which the shape of the free surface is part of the answer.

applied · Jet Three contours, one force, three different accounts of it. The same vortex, and the same total force on it, computed by a momentum balance over three contours of the same area. All three give ρUΓ to eight figures. What differs is the bookkeeping: the tall box gets 16 per cent of it from pressure and the rest from momentum flux, the wide box gets 84 per cent from pressure, and the circle gets exactly half. Neither part converges on its own as the contour is enlarged — each falls off like 1/r while the contour grows like r — so the split is a property of the shape of the limit rather than of the flow.

Where the reaction to a wing's lift is

The force on a body can be computed on any contour drawn round it, and the answer is the same every time. How much of that answer is pressure and how much is momentum flux is not — it runs from three per cent to ninety-seven, and the difference is the shape of the contour.

inviscid · Far field The jet divides 75% to 25%. A jet striking a plate at 60 degrees. Both sheets leave at the jet's own speed, because their surfaces are at ambient pressure and Bernoulli allows nothing else, and the plate can exert no force along itself because the fluid has no viscosity. Momentum along the plate then fixes the split at (1 + cos β)/2 = 0.7500, and the normal force at ṁV sin β = 0.8660. Nothing about the plate's material, size or roughness enters either.

What a jet cannot push sideways

A jet striking a plate divides in two, and how it divides is fixed by a single sentence — an inviscid fluid exerts no force along a surface. That one statement, plus mass, gives the split exactly — and the same sentence turns a flat plate into a bucket worth twice as much.

applied · Jet Most power at exactly half the jet speed, found by search at 0.5000. The power a bucket takes from a jet, against how fast the bucket runs, for four deflection angles. Every curve is a parabola with roots at zero — where the force is greatest and the bucket is not moving — and at the jet speed, where the bucket is running away and there is no force at all. The peak is halfway between, at U = V/2, and it is there for every angle and every flow rate. A golden-section search that knows none of the algebra puts it at 0.500000.

Half the jet speed takes everything

A bucket standing still feels the largest force and does no work; a bucket running with the jet does no work either. Between them the power peaks at exactly half the jet speed, for every bucket shape and every flow rate — and at that speed a perfect bucket leaves the water motionless.

applied · Jet A material region, and the dye that stays inside it. The same fluid at four times, carried by an unsteady straining flow whose strain rate oscillates. The outline is a circle of the fluid at the first instant, tracked by integrating the velocity field; the shading is a blob of passive dye. The region is stretched to nearly seven to one and its area is unchanged to fifteen decimal places, because the flow is incompressible. The amount of dye inside it is unchanged to thirteen, because the dye is carried by the same fluid.

A rate of change that will not hold still

Three boxes drawn in one flow at one instant give three different answers to how fast the dye inside them is changing — one falling, one falling twice as fast, one rising. All three reconcile with a single material rate, and that rate is zero.

kinematics · Transport theorem Where the suction on a cylinder is actually made. The share of the surface's pressure deficit generated within a given distance of it. Twelve per cent comes from the first twentieth of a radius, half from within a third, and a tenth of it from beyond one and a half radii. There is no thin layer doing the work: the suction is made by the curvature of the whole outer field.

The effect that is real, and where it stops

The Coandă effect has a genuine mechanism, and it is the same equation that makes the suction on a wing. What separates the two is where the integral comes from: a wall jet generates all of its pressure deficit inside a layer two per cent of the radius thick, and a cylinder in a stream needs a third of a radius for half of it.

misconceptions · Coanda 12 bar from stopping one metre per second. The head at the valve after it shuts, computed by the method of characteristics on a 600 m pipe. The rise is 122.4 m of water, which is ρaΔV/ρg to 1.4e-14 m — and the scheme was told neither ρaΔV nor anything else about the answer. The wave then runs to the reservoir and back every 2.000 s, and with no friction in the model it never decays: a real pipe damps this out in a few tens of cycles.

Stopping water costs more than moving it

Shut a valve on water running at one metre per second and the pressure that appears is twelve bar — not because the water was pushing hard, but because the only way to stop a column of fluid is to send a message back along it, and the message travels at the speed of sound in the pipe.

applied · Water hammer A pump curve out of the momentum theorem. The pressure an ejector delivers, against how much it is entraining, at a fixed nozzle. It has the shape of every pump characteristic ever measured — a shut-off pressure with no flow, falling to no pressure at free delivery — and it was obtained from a momentum balance on a tube with nothing in it. The shut-off value here is 36.0 kPa and the machine at its best power runs at 4.56 times its own motive flow.

Mixing is a pump

Two streams at different speeds mixing in a tube destroy energy — the same Borda–Carnot expression a handbook prints beside a sudden enlargement, with two streams in it instead of one. And while they destroy it the pressure rises, which makes the loss the mechanism of a machine with no moving parts.

applied · Ejector A uniform scalar in a fluid at rest, under two face rules. Nothing is flowing and the scalar starts at one everywhere. The swept-volume rule leaves it at one to the last bit, at every step of the two time units. The midpoint rule moves it by two parts in ten thousand, on a mesh motion that begins and ends in the same place, and the excursion looks exactly like a physical transient.

The mesh that makes its own mass

The transport theorem holds for a region moving at any velocity, which is what makes a moving-mesh calculation possible. Discretised carelessly it is not an identity but an approximation, and a fluid at rest with a uniform density then gains density from the motion of a grid — smoothly, plausibly, and looking exactly like a physical transient.

kinematics · Transport theorem Same disc, same solidity, different number of blades, different answer. Thrust and power coefficients for six blade counts at a fixed solidity. They span a factor of 1.101 in thrust, and every one of those rotors is the same actuator disc: same area, same blade area, same tip-speed ratio. The disc theory cannot distinguish them because the blade count is not one of its variables.

A disc that knows no blades

Momentum theory replaces a rotor with a surface across which the pressure jumps, and gets the Betz limit, the induced velocity and the whole energy argument out of it. It has no chord, no section and no number of blades — and at one fixed solidity, two blades and twenty give thrust coefficients ten per cent apart.

circulation · Blade-element Four wakes carrying exactly the same drag. Four velocity-deficit profiles behind a body, each normalised so that the integral of the deficit across the wake is exactly the same. That integral is the drag: the far-wake momentum balance says so with no assumption about the shape of anything. The four are a narrow Gaussian, a wide top hat, the two-lobed wake a body with a splitter plate leaves, and a profile with heavy tails.

Exact in the total, free in the profile

A constraint is one number imposed on a function. Four wakes built to carry exactly the same drag differ by a factor of four and a half in their peak deficit, and the general statement behind that is a question about angles: how much of the wanted answer survives being projected off the constraints, and how much does not.

regimes · Dimensional Four guesses at a boundary-layer profile. A straight line, a parabola, Pohlhausen's cubic and a quarter sine, each rising from zero at the wall to the free stream at the edge. Two of them also satisfy the conditions the true profile satisfies — no curvature at the wall, no slope at the edge — and two do not, which is what sorts them.

Four profiles, one drag

The momentum integral is exact and asks nothing about the shape of the velocity profile. Four guesses at that shape span twenty-three per cent in the drag they give — and the two that satisfy the conditions the true profile satisfies are within three, which says the freedom belongs to the family rather than to the constraint.

viscous · Boundary layer Four fluids under the same stress, and the four profiles that result. Each fluid carries the same linear stress and answers it differently: a Newtonian fluid with a parabola, a shear-thinning one with a blunter profile, a shear-thickening one with a sharper one, and a Bingham plastic with a plug in the middle where the stress is below its yield point.

The stress a pipe knows

A capillary viscometer measures a pressure drop and a flow rate and reports a viscosity. The first half of that inference is a force balance and is exact for any fluid there is; the second needs the slope of a whole flow curve, which is the experiment the instrument was bought to avoid.

viscous · Non-newtonian Two wakes with one drag. The two initial velocity deficits: a slab, which is roughly what a bluff body leaves, and a pair of separated lobes, which is roughly what a body with a jet through the middle of it leaves. Their integrals are identical, so the two bodies have exactly the same drag.

A wake that keeps the drag and forgets the body

Two very different wakes with the same momentum deficit converge to the same profile, because the deficit is conserved and everything else diffuses away. The convergence is a power law rather than an exponential, so it takes two hundred widths for twenty per cent agreement and nine hundred for five.

turbulence · Wake A cone sends 1.7 per cent of its jet's momentum sideways at 15°. A conical divergent section of 15° half-angle and exit area ratio 25, drawn to scale from its throat to its lip, with its virtual apex to the left. The gas leaves as a source flow: straight streamlines from the apex, each at its own angle, and a Mach number uniform on spheres centred there. On the spherical cap through the lip the flow is normal to the surface and uniform, at Mach 3.925 for a gas with γ = 1.2; its axial momentum is ρV² times the cap's projection onto the exit disc, while the mass crossing it is ρV times the cap itself. The ratio of the two areas is (1 + cos α)/2 = 0.9830, and it is the only thing the cone's shape does to the momentum. On the flat exit plane the flow is not uniform: its edge is further from the apex than its centre, and the Mach number there is higher.

The jet a cone sprays sideways

The one-dimensional nozzle sends all its gas straight out along the axis. A real divergent section is a cone, and the gas leaves it as a spray of straight lines from the cone's apex. Only the axial part of that momentum pushes, and the share that does is (1 + cos α)/2 — 98.3 per cent at fifteen degrees, 93.3 at thirty — whatever the gas, the Mach number or the area ratio, and it touches the momentum and never the pressure.

compressible · Area mach A water sheet two millimetres thick leaves the lip above 0.270 m/s. The effective tension of a sheet of water, 2σ − ρU²h per metre of its width, against the speed it is poured at, for sheets one, two and four millimetres thick. At rest every sheet carries the tension of its two surfaces, 145.4 mN/m, and the momentum it carries along itself subtracts from that. A 1 mm sheet reaches zero at 0.382 m/s, a 2 mm sheet reaches zero at 0.270 m/s and a 4 mm sheet reaches zero at 0.191 m/s. Below its own crossing a sheet bent round a lip is pulled onto it; above, it is flung off. The quantity that decides is a tension, not a pressure, and the speed at which it vanishes is the speed of waves along the sheet.

The teapot effect is a tension, not a pressure

A slow pour runs back under a spout and down its outside, and the name it is usually given is the Coandă effect. The Coandă effect borrows the ambient pressure, and a liquid in air has none to borrow. A liquid sheet is held to a lip by its own surface tension, and it lets go at the one speed that tension cannot carry — the speed of waves along the sheet — whatever the lip's radius.

misconceptions · Coanda Momentum theory answers every descent rate except those between hover and twice the hover inflow. The induced velocity at a rotor disc against its climb speed, both in units of the hover induced velocity √(T/2ρA), at fixed thrust. The climb branch (thick) solves v(V + v) = 1 and is a streamtube for every climb and for hover, where v = 1. Continued into descent (dashed) it still has a root, but the air it describes leaves the tube at both ends. The windmill-brake branch (thin) solves v(V + v) = −1 and is real only for descent faster than two hover inflows, where it meets v = 1 again. Between V = −2 and V = 0 (shaded) neither is a streamtube. The faint diagonal is v = −V, where the rotor would need no power: it crosses the band and touches neither valid branch.

Between hover and twice the hover inflow

A rotor's momentum balance has an answer for every climb and for every fast descent, and none for descending at anything between zero and twice its own hover inflow. There one root sends air out of both ends of its streamtube and the other root is not a real number, and at each edge of the band one end of the tube stops moving — which is where the vortex ring state lives, and where a wind turbine's thrust coefficient of one sits.

applied · Actuator disc The induced velocity, after a step in thrust. A rotor's induced velocity following a thirty per cent increase in thrust applied at fifty milliseconds. It does not jump: the air the disc has to accelerate has an apparent mass, and the response is a first-order climb to the new momentum-theory value.

The inflow that takes time to arrive

Momentum theory gives a rotor's induced velocity from its thrust, instantly. It does not arrive instantly: the air the disc has to accelerate has a mass, and the response is a first-order climb with a time constant of 33 milliseconds — a twentieth of the time the wake itself takes to convect a radius.

circulation · Blade-element

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Control volumeConservationModel limitMeasurementMomentum fluxActuator discBernoulli's equationEfficiencyMisconceptionThe Betz limitThrustCirculation

All concepts